No preview available
HomeMy WebLinkAbout10/06/2008 Item 018 MOHA VE COUNTY REQUEST FOR BOARD ACTION FORM From Barbara Bracken, Clerk of the Board FORMAL ACTION 0 CONSENT 0 Date September 22, 2008 RESOLUTION 0 OTHER 0 BOS Meetmg Date October 6, 2008 INFORMATION ONLY 0 SUMMARIZE THE ISSUE & DESIRED ACTION CLEARLY/ATTACH BACKUP MATERIAL Recommended MotIOn Slttmg as the Mohave County Board of EqualIzatIon Approve the Board of EqualizatIon Hearmg Officer s recommendatIOns regardmg PetItIOns for RevIew of Real Property ValuatIOn heard on September 16 17 18 19 23 and 24 2008 ReViewed and Approved By County Attorney 0 Human Resources 0 Fmance 0 Board Action Taken Approved as Requested 0 No ActIOn Taken 0 DIsapproved 0 Contmued to o Approved WIth the followmg changes Acknowledged receIpt and referred to Fdmg InformatIon and Retneval Flied BId Flied Agreement BOS ResolutIOn Flied Yearly Correspondence Flied PetItion Flied DedIcatIOn Flied Land Sold Flied Land AcqUired Flied FranchIse I D ResolutIOn Flied Improvement DIstnct Flied Other Date Routed AddItional InformatIOn XC \ ~ - ------- October 3 2008 112029AM HEARING OFFICER S RECOMMENDATION Parcel Owner's Tax Legal Owner's Assessor's Assessor's Assessor's BofE LPV DeCISion Comments Number Name Agents Class Opmlon Ongmal ReVised BOE DecIsion I Name (FCV) (FCV) (FCV) (FCV) (FCV) 09/16/2008 l Field 106-03-086 MeSSier Kallo & Patti 03 $155000 $203 392 $178494 $156172 $156172 $142 680 Mid StIpulation l Field 115-06-455 MeSSier Kallo & Patti 03 $150000 $260 663 $197508 $170282 $170282 $170 282 Mid Stipulation l - Field 108-07 123A Guenn Wilma I 03 $193534 $227 965 $224 549 $224 549 $224 549 $180688 Mkt Stipulation l Field 10934-027 lester Jeffory 0 03 $573 000 $846 723 $793611 $659515 $659515 $659515 Mkt Stipulation l- Field 110 13 225 Kortegast Nancy 03 $200 000 $398 337 $394 531 $349 041 $349041 $301 599 Mid Stipulation l Field 11312103 Chapman David 03 $370 000 $378 000 $370 000 $323 375 $323 375 $323 375 Mid Stipulation B Field 213-68-o04A Wolf Bernard & Joann 03 $195000 $213539 $213 539 $195000 $195000 $195000 Mid Stipulation B - Field 214 16-o50A Magruder Gerald 04 $506 534 $759655 $759 655 $506 534 $506 534 $465 572 Inc Stipulation B Field 21436-026 Wilson James & Enka 03 $329 116 $504 028 $504 028 $504 028 $504 028 $429 550 Mkt B Field 229-06 042 Cullen Frank & Karen 03 $93 000 $152315 $152315 $117795 $117 795 $108881 Mid Stipulation K - Field 241 04-020 Allen Terry & lOls 03 $112546 $220 407 $191 846 $170927 $170927 $122053 Cost K Field 31221-014 McGnff Richard & James MX ? $7 959 $7 959 $7 959 $7 959 $5 646 Cost K Field 322 23-088 Roundy Michael 03 $444 000 $513123 $513123 $513123 $480 000 $480 000 Mkt K Field 324 03-182 Ekonomus Journallnc 04 $16825 $33 090 $29 783 $16604 $16604 $14503 Mid Stipulation K Field 329 04-503 lucas Kenneth 03 $75 608 $101 110 $84 834 $75 608 $75 608 $73 734 Mid Stipulation K - Field 333 35-013 DeVice Richard & Ella Karen 03 $85 000 $241 749 $215831 $215831 $215831 $194099 Cost K Field 354 39-002 King Mark & Toni MX $201 147 $327 009 $256 557 $256 557 $256 557 $172005 Cost B Field 21050-037 Pawlik Paul 03 $10000 $67719 $67719 $67719 $67719 $52 908 Cost B Field 210 50-038 Horne Peter 04 $10000 $50 789 $50 789 $50 789 $50 789 $39 681 Cost B Field 21807016 Home Peter 04 $10000 $34 659 $34 659 $34 659 $34 659 $26 768 Cost K - Field 306 12 207 A Horne Peter 04 $10000 $51 929 $51 929 $51 929 $51 929 $31 249 Cost K Field 306 16-0200 Horne Peter 04 $15000 $38813 $31 878 $31 878 $31 878 $23 222 Cost K - Field 306 16-2028 Horne Peter 04 $10000 $39 033 $39 033 $39 033 $39 033 $23 601 Cost K land 311 10-047 Horne Peter 2R ? $27 200 $27 200 $19 448 $19448 $13 601 Mkt Stipulation K Field 324-08 155 Ekonomus Journallnc 03 $13 825 $42 687 $38 365 $16797 $16797 $14671 Mid Stipulation 09/17/2008 K land 101 23-002 Dlednch Michael 2R $78 000 $137520 $137520 $78 000 $78 000 $78 000 Mkt Stipulation K land 101-24002 Dlednch Michael 2R $26 000 $65 040 $65 040 $46 240 $46 240 $31 060 Mkt Stipulation K land 102-17-040 Redell Jerry A 2R $5 000 $21 920 $21 920 $21 920 $21 920 $7 721 Mid K - land 102-20-006 Murdock Everett & Susan 2R $4 180 $21 920 $21 920 $21 920 $21 920 $8615 Mid l land 10626210 Miner James & leslle 2R ? $88 063 $88 063 $69 407 $69 407 $69 407 Mid Stipulation K - land 124-13-007 Roth Wilham & Jonne 2R $6 920 $51 000 $27 424 $25160 $25 160 $10278 Mid StipulatIon K land 204-40 002A Hoover John & Deborah 2R $50 000 $102680 $102680 $102680 $102680 $60 526 Mkt Stipulation K land 20623015 Nutt T & C Trustee 2R $506 304 $1 878599 $1 878599 $882 736 $882 736 $840 055 Mkt Stipulation K Land 206 28 033 Jobin Mark T 2R $58 164 $263 659 $62 300 $56 164 $56 164 $56 164 Mkt Stipulation 206 28-034 Jobin Mark T 2R $63 285 $269919 $155769 $88 089 $88 089 $69614 Mkt K land 206 28-052A Hays Carl W 2R $61 524 $266 253 $218068 $178 384 $159720 $86 920 Mkt K land 206 28 067 Mc Alpine Peter & Susan 2R $61 478 $266 053 $266 053 $152785 $147630 $84 938 Mid K - land 208 36 251 Grady Patncla 2R $75000 $9 788 $9 788 $9 788 $9 788 $4 983 Mid Stipulation Bland 21024-069 Goddard Robert & Diana 2R $10000 $16500 $16500 $13999 $13999 $12098 Mkt Stipulation Page 1 of 14 October 3, 2008 112029AM HEARING OFFICER S RECOMMENDATION Parcel Owner's Tax Legal Owner's Assessor's Assessor's Assessor's BofE LPV DecIsion Comments Number Name Agent s Class Opinion Original Revised BOE DecIsion I Name (FCY) (FCY) (FCY) (FCY) (FCY) BLand 21024119 Grau Philippe 2R ? $24 498 $24 498 $19922 $19922 $16487 Mkt B - Land 21024120 Grau Philippe 2R ? $15511 $15 511 $11 845 $11 845 $10662 Mkt B - Land 21051 192 Sykes Evelyn 2R $15000 $38 148 $18496 $15000 $15000 $15000 Mkt Stipulation BLand 21051 193 Sykes Evelyn 2R $20 000 $90168 $43717 $29 446 $29 446 $29 446 Mkt Stipulation BLand 213 14-061 AZ. Land & Minerai Resource LLC 2R $440 790 $1 886035 $1 363 301 $440 790 $440 790 $440 790 Mkt Stipulation BLand 214 33 564 Zimmerman Derrick 2R $30 000 $48 871 $48 871 $22 200 $22 200 $22 200 Mkt Stipulation B - Land 216-11-087 Lucas Kenneth 2R $3 375 $79 406 $79 406 $8 552 $8 552 $4 669 Mkt Stipulation B - Land 220-05-024 Mattson Ken 2R $50 000 $83 432 $83 432 $47 954 $47954 $39310 Mkt Stipulation BLand 220-05-076 Mattson Ken 2R $50 000 $106353 $106353 $61 128 $61 128 $45 455 Mkt Stipulation BLand 220-05-075 Mattson Ken 2R $50 000 $106353 $106353 $61 128 $61 128 $45 455 Mkt Stipulation B - Land 220-05-097A Mattson Ken 2R $15000 $36 069 $36 069 $26 354 $26 354 $18411 Mkt Stipulation B - Land 220-05 116 Mattson Ken 2R $50 000 $88 933 $88 933 $51 116 $51 116 $41 900 Mkt Stipulation BLand 222-18-064 Cheshire Dwaln & Evelyn 2R $50 000 $93 361 $70 693 $53116 $53 116 $53116 Mkt Stipulation K Land 225 22-030 Bay Douglas & Trudl 2R $228 654 $1 040868 $945 369 $361 525 $361 525 $359 368 Mkt Stipulation B - Land 225 27 002 HugginS Earl & Mamell 2R $82 867 $166377 $95 200 $82 866 $82 866 $69 857 Mkt Stipulation 09/18/2008 BLand 22216005 EI RIO Professional Plaza LLC 2R $70 000 $103459 $70 262 $70 262 $70 262 $56 878 Mkt Stipulation 22216006 EI RIO Professional Plaza LLC 2R $70 000 $236 323 $160494 $160494 $160494 $129922 Mkt 22216-007 EI RIO ProfeSSional Plaza LLC 2R $70 000 $116557 $79158 $79 158 $79158 $64 079 Mkt BLand 225-19-003 Hoover Quality Homes 2R $151 755 $254 060 $221 970 $148970 $148 970 $137764 Mkt Stipulation 225 19-004 Hoover Quality Homes 2R $151 755 $254 060 $221 970 $148970 $148970 $137764 Mkt 225 19-020 Hoover Quality Homes 1 $2 209 945 $4464 171 $4 464 171 N Change N-Change N Change N/A Split - Sep Notice BLand 225 22 028 #3 USC LLC 03 $880 179 $1 455560 $1 421 948 $841 976 $841 976 $497 838 Mkt Stipulation BLand 22522-037 FATCO Manposa II 2R $789 000 $1 000000 $821 887 $749169 $749169 $684 805 Mkt Stipulation BLand 22522-038 FATCO Manposa VI 2R $789 000 $1 339404 $843 968 $769 307 $769 307 $769 307 Mkt Stipulation BLand 22522-039 FATCO Manposa I (PHVVII VIII) 2R $0 $8 425 646 $8 425 646 N-Change N Change N-Change N/A Split Sep Notice BLand 22522-040 FATCO - Manposa IV 2R $789 000 $1 000000 $832 762 $759 092 $759 092 $446 909 Mkt Stipulation B - Land 22522-041 FATCO Manposa III 2R $789 000 $1 000000 $832 762 $759 092 $759 092 $446 909 Mkt Stipulation BLand 22522-042 FATCO Manposa I 2R $789 000 $1 000000 $821 876 $749169 $749 169 $443 504 Mkt Stipulation BLand 22522043 FATCO HQHlManposa V & VIII 2R $3 884 676 $7 068 966 $7 068 966 N Change N Change N Change N/A Split - Sep Notice BLand 225 22-044 Manposa Phase VII LLC 2R $789 000 $1 000000 $1 356680 $779 229 $779 229 $460 737 Mkt Stipulation BLand 225-66-003 EI RIO Country Club LLC 2R $90 000 $227 137 $86812 $81 460 $81 460 $81 460 Mkt Stipulation 225-66-004 EI RIO Country Club LLC 2R $90 000 $317648 $238 375 $133878 $133 878 $133878 Mkt 225-66-005 EI RIO Country Club LLC 2R $90 000 $239 239 $179534 $100831 $100831 $100831 Mkt 225-66 006 EI RIO Country Club LLC 2R $90 000 $136867 $136867 $76 853 $76 853 $76 853 Mkt 225-66-007 EI RIO Country Club LLC 2R $90 000 $137291 $137291 $77 091 $77 091 $77 091 Mkt 225 66-057 EI RIO Country Club LLC 2R $90 000 $120571 $120571 $67 703 $67 703 $67 703 Mkt 225-66120 EI RIO Country Club LLC 2R $90 000 $139159 $139159 $78 140 $78 140 $78 140 Mkt 225-66 148 EI RIO Country Club LLC 2R $90 000 $118783 $118783 $66 699 $66 699 $66 699 Mkt BLand 228-04154 Hoover Brothers Rentals LLC 2R $75 877 $244 400 $244 400 N-Change N Change N Change N/A Split Sep Notice 228 04-233 Hoover Brothers Rentals LLC 2R $283174 $466 500 $466 500 N-Change N Change N Change N/A Split Sep Notice BLand 228-07-007 Hoover Brothers Rentals LLC 2R $30 000 $49291 $49 291 N Change N Change N-Change Mkt Stipulation 228-07 015 Hoover Brothers Rentals LLC 2R $30 000 $50 873 $50 873 N Change N Change N Change Mkt Page 2 of 14 October 3, 2008 112029AM HEARING OFFICER S RECOMMENDATION Parcel Owner's Tax Legal Owner's Assessor's Assessor's Assessor's BofE LPV DecIsion Comments Number Name Agent s Class Opmlon Ongmal Revised BOE DecIsion I Name (FCY) (FCY) (FCY) (FCV) (FCY) BLand 22608-018 Rigby Robert 2R ? $147984 $147 984 $139368 $139368 $85 965 Mid B - Land 229 22-028E Dlvlzla Mary Jo Trustee 2R $170000 $691 596 $628 145 $628 145 $532 390 $377 571 Mid K - Land 242 11 002 Llebensberger Mernll & Estrella 2R $55 563 $80801 $72 909 $55 563 $55 563 $40 713 Mid Stipulation K Land 245-04-004 Tracy Larry & Beverley 2R $40 000 $147676 $147676 $75 339 $75 339 $20 599 Mid K Land 25221-001 Smith Arthur L 2R $22321 $127499 $127499 $94 789 $94 788 $35 672 Mkt Stipulation 252 21-002 2R $22321 $127499 $127499 $94 789 $94 788 $35 672 Mid K - Land 25221-011 Hansell David W JT 50 2R $25121 $140677 $140677 $104 626 $104626 $52 352 Mid K Land 25223-016 Hansell David W JT 50 2R $27 864 $156038 $156038 $116051 $116051 $65 108 Mkt K - Land 312-09236 Hansell David & Teresa B 2R $818 $5 884 $5 884 $4 762 $4 762 $1 744 Mkt 312-09 237 $818 $5 884 $5 884 $4 762 $4 762 $1 744 Mid K Land 334-08 177B Hansell David & Teresa B 2R $788 $1 188 $1 188 N Change N Change N Change Mid K Land 353 09-005 Hansell David & Teresa B 2R $1 005 $7 345 $6 660 $6 660 $6 660 $3 780 Mkt 353 09-036A $1 005 $7 345 $6 660 $6 660 $6 660 $3 780 Mid K - Land 301 11 014 Graybehl Rawland 2R $1 250 $153180 $153180 N Change N Change N Change Mid K Land 306-08-083 Apt Ronald & Paula 2R $17 000 $243 508 $24 563 N-Change N Change N Change Mid Stipulation K - Land 306 34-0040 Gay Noble & Laura 2R $15000 $40 950 $33 997 $25 112 $25112 $16046 Mid K - Land 306 34-004E Gay Noble & Laura 2R $18000 $40 950 $40 950 $33 482 $33 482 $18139 Mkt 09/19/2008 l- FIeld 10624-043 Hav A Storage Inc 112 ? $1205803 $737 864 $737 864 $737 864 $737 864 Income Stipulation 106 24-044 1 12 ? $1 351 467 $827 000 $827 000 $827 000 $827 000 106 24-050 1 12 ? $350 841 $214689 $214689 $214689 $214689 106 24 093 1 12 ? $1 009499 $617740 $617740 $617740 $617 740 106 24-094 1 12 ? $613052 $375 143 $375143 $375143 $375143 106 24-095 1 12 ? $1 001 328 $612740 $612740 $612740 $612740 B Field 220-45-001 Gold Rush I LP 04 $88 109 $161 890 $161 890 $114894 $114894 $114894 Income Stipulation 220-45-002 04 $88 109 $161 890 $161 890 $114894 $114894 $114894 220-45-003 04 $88 109 $161 890 $161 890 $114894 $114894 $114894 220-45-004 04 $88 109 $161 890 $161 890 $114894 $114894 $114894 220-45 005 04 $88 109 $161 890 $161 890 $114894 $114894 $114894 220-45-006 04 $88 109 $161 890 $161 890 $114894 $114894 $114894 220-45-007 04 $88 109 $161 890 $161 890 $114893 $114893 $114893 220-45-008 04 $88109 $161 890 $161 890 $114893 $114893 $114893 220-45-009 04 $88 109 $161 890 $161 890 $114893 $114893 $114893 220-45 010 04 $88 109 $161 890 $161 890 $114893 $114893 $114893 220-45 011 04 $88 109 $161 890 $161 890 $114893 $114893 $114893 220-45-012 04 $88 109 $161 890 $161 890 $114893 $114893 $114893 220-45 013 04 $88109 $161 890 $161 890 $114893 $114893 $114893 220-45014 04 $1 000 $1 000 $1 000 $1 000 $1 000 $1 000 220-45-015 04 $1 000 $1 000 $1 000 $1 000 $1 000 $1 000 220-45016 04 $1 000 $1 000 $1 000 $1 000 $1 000 $1 000 220-45 017 04 $1 000 $1 000 $1 000 $1 000 $1 000 $1 000 220-47 001 Gold Rush II LP 04 $88 109 $161 890 $161 890 $114893 $114893 $114893 220-47-002 04 $88109 $161 890 $161 890 $114893 $114893 $114893 Page 3 of 14 October 3 2008 112029AM HEARING OFFICER S RECOMMENDATION Parcel Owner's Tax Legal Owner's Assessor's Assessor's Assessor's BofE LPV DeCISion Comments Number Name Agents Class Opinion Original Revised BOE DeCISion I Name (FCY) (FCY) (FCV) (FCY) (FCY) 220-47-003 04 $88 109 $161 890 $161 890 $114893 $114893 $114893 220-47-004 04 $88 109 $161 890 $161 890 $114893 $114893 $114893 220-47-005 04 $88 109 $161 890 $161 890 $114893 $114893 $114893 220-47-006 04 $88109 $161 890 $161 890 $114893 $114893 $114 893 220-47-007 04 $88 109 $161 890 $161 890 $114893 $114893 $114 893 220-47-008 04 $88 109 $161890 $161 890 $114893 $114893 $114 893 220-47009 04 $88 109 $161 890 $161 890 $114893 $114893 $114893 220-47-010 04 $88 109 $161 890 $161 890 $114893 $114893 $114893 220-47-011 04 $88 109 $161 890 $161 890 $114893 $114893 $114893 220-47-012 04 $88 109 $161 890 $161 890 $114893 $114893 $114893 220-47-013 04 $88 109 $161 890 $161 890 $114893 $114893 $114893 220-47-014 04 $88 109 $161 890 $161 890 $114893 $114893 $114893 220-47-015 04 $88 109 $161 890 $161 890 $114893 $114893 $114893 220-47-016 04 $88 109 $161 890 $161 890 $114893 $114893 $114893 220-47-017 04 $88 109 $161 890 $161 890 $114893 $114893 $114893 220-47-018 04 $88 109 $161 890 $161 890 $114893 $114893 $114893 220-47-019 04 $88 109 $161 890 $161 890 $114893 $114893 $114893 220-47-020 04 $88 109 $161 890 $161 890 $114893 $114893 $114893 220-47-021 04 $88 109 $161 890 $161 890 $114893 $114893 $114893 220-47-022 04 $88 109 $161 890 $161 890 $114893 $114893 $114893 220-47-023 04 $88 109 $161 890 $161 890 $114893 $114893 $114893 220-47024 04 $88 109 $161 890 $161 890 $114893 $114893 $114893 220-47-025 04 $100953 $100953 $100953 $100953 $100953 $100953 220-47-026 04 $1 000 $1 000 $1 000 $1 000 $1 000 $1 000 220-47-027 04 $1 000 $1 000 $1 000 $1 000 $1 000 $1 000 L - Field 105-03 115B Blue Sun Investments LLC MX $219155 $252 061 $252061 $239016 $239016 $217144 Cost Stipulation 105-03116 Blue Sun Investments LLC 1 $61 842 $78 468 $78 468 $71 945 $71 945 $71 945 K Field 305 18-033A Helens Place Adult LIVing L TD 04 $343 034 $571 723 $571 723 N Change N Change N Change N/A Split - Sep Notice K Field 320 24-003 CTW Kingman LLC 1 $7600000 $10482659 $10482659 N Change N Change N-Change N/A Split Sep Notice B - Land 226-02-009 Kaplan Robert Trustee 2R $50 250 $774 868 $774 868 $731 667 $731 667 $384 736 Mid 227 20-037 2R $362 850 $4 226 622 $4226622 $2916164 $2916164 $1 787413 BLand 228-02-093 Kaplan Robert Trustee 2R $349 930 $5135000 $5 135 000 $4 845 023 $4 845 023 $3 060 811 Mid K - Land 320-03-231 Kaplan Robert Trustee 2R $1 614 065 $2 386 586 $2 386 586 N-Change N Change N-Change N/A Split Sep Notice L - Land 105 27-001 Premier Homes LH DIV 2R $500 $127278 $44 403 $41 738 $41 738 $41 738 Mid 105 27-002 2R $500 $127278 $44 403 $41 738 $41 738 $41 738 10527003 2R $500 $127278 $44 403 $41 738 $41 738 $41 738 10527-004 2R $500 $127278 $44 403 $41 738 $41 738 $41 738 09/23/2008 K - Land 312-09-417 Villani LUigi & Fllomena 2R $1 000 $5 507 $5 507 $4 457 $4 457 $1 645 Mid K Land 312-09-418 Villani LUIgi & Fllomena 2R $1 100 $5 884 $5 884 $4 762 $4 762 $1 744 Mkt K Land 31331-014 Gilbertson Les 2R $100000 $237612 $194085 $194085 $194085 $95 902 Mid Stipulation K Land 31355-014 Kelesldes Nick 2R $16619 $165000 $165000 $165000 $165000 $79 305 2007 BOE Page 4 of 14 October 3 2008 112029AM HEARING OFFICER S RECOMMENDATION Parcel Owner's Tax Legal Owner's Assessor's Assessor's Assessor's 80fE LPV DecIsion Comments Number Name Agents Class Opinion Onglnal ReVised 80E DecIsion I Name (FCV) (FCY) (FCY) (FCY) (FCV) K Land 317-042968 Chapman Conrad & Jacklyn 2R $61 248 $83 985 $81 195 $81 195 $81 195 $40 834 Mkt Stipulation 317-04 2958 2R $18418 $27 995 $27 065 $27 065 $27 065 $15013 K Land 317-09-0458 Chapman Conrad & Jacklyn 2R $19500 $43 170 $43 170 $19500 $19500 $9 707 Mkt Stipulation 317-09-065 2R $19500 $43 170 $43 170 $19500 $19500 $9 707 K Land 317 38-008E Smengho Frank & UnJu 2R $30 000 $32819 $32819 $23 170 $23 170 $23 170 Mkt Stipulation K Land 317 38-008F Smengho Frank & UnJu 2R $30 000 $32819 $32819 $23 170 $23 170 $23 170 Mkt Stipulation K Land 317-43-008 River Canyon LLC 2R $27751 $86 551 $86 551 $86551 $86551 $33 831 Mkt Stipulation 317-43045 2R $27751 $86 551 $86551 $86551 $86 551 $33831 317-43046 2R $27751 $86551 $86551 $86551 $86 551 $33 831 317-43068 2R $27751 $86 551 $86 551 $86 551 $86 551 $33 831 317-43-091 2R $27 751 $86 551 $86 551 $64 916 $64916 $28 442 317-43109 2R $27 751 $86 551 $86 551 $86551 $86 551 $33831 317-43117 2R $27751 $86 551 $86 551 $86551 $86 551 $33831 K - Land 319-09-004 Murray Ivan & Joyce 2R $7 700 $64 000 $64 000 $64 000 $59 000 $18751 Mkt K Land 319 11-018 Meyer Jeff A 2R $10000 $84 240 $53 892 $52510 $52510 $29 763 Mkt K - Land 326 10-037A Cantrell Robert 2R $39 000 $70 140 $70 140 $70140 $70 140 $40 885 Mkt Stipulation 326 10-0378 2R $19500 $35 070 $35 070 $35 070 $35 070 $21 032 326 10-037C 2R $19500 $35 070 $35 070 $35 070 $35 070 $21 032 32610 128 2R $19 500 $35 070 $35 070 $35 070 $35 070 $21 032 K Land 334-11-042 TrOise John A 2R $2415 $16240 $16240 $16240 $16240 $5103 Mkt K - Land 334-11-043 TrOise John A 2R $2415 $16240 $16240 $16240 $16240 $5103 Mkt K - Land 346-06-050A Mallett Ronald & Jeffn 2R $7 500 $41 547 $15607 $7 500 $7 500 $7 500 Mkt K - Land 346 06 051 Mallett Ronald & Jeffn 2R $7 500 $31 783 $34812 $27 873 $23 521 $11 505 Mkt K Land 33921 169E Beller Roy B & Virginia B 2R $15000 $29 227 $29 227 $29 227 $29 227 $16290 Mkt Stipulation K Land 21606010 Nayen Majid 2R $0 $12250 $12250 $12250 $9 225 $6 593 Mkt 216-06 058 2R $0 $11 687 $11 687 $11 687 $8 800 $6 289 216-06-059 2R $0 $11 687 $11 687 $11 687 $8 800 $6 289 K Land 340-24-0958 Nayen Majid 2R $7 500 $13860 $13860 $8 063 $8 063 $6 927 Mkt Stipulation 340 24 1088 2R $6 000 $13860 $12168 $8 063 $8 063 $6 927 340 24 109 2R $11 000 $34 760 $19120 $16125 $16125 $12016 340-24-097 2R $20 000 $34 760 $31 290 $16125 $16125 $12016 34024-111 2R $20 000 $34 760 $34 760 $16125 $16125 $12016 K - Land 330 09-036 Nayerl Majid 2R $50 000 $92 240 $86637 $86 637 $86 637 $62 962 Mkt K Land 35012174 Nayerl Majid 2R $32 000 $123761 $59 700 $59 700 $59 700 $38 826 Mkt K Land 33925-019 Garden City Investment LLC 2R $140850 $268291 $232 966 $194614 $194614 $92 109 Mkt Stipulation K Land 339-47 009 Ford Henry 2R $55 000 $142896 $124081 $124081 $124081 $69 284 Mkt Stipulation K Land 209-02 232 Summitt Wilham & Christine 2R $6 996 $15024 $15024 $8178 $8 178 $4 078 Mkt Stipulation 209-02-016 2R $6162 $13234 $13 234 $7 204 $7 204 $3 678 K Land 34317324 Summitt Wilham & Chnstlne 2R $16634 $38 260 $38 260 $38 260 $38 260 $17265 Mkt Stipulation K Land 343 21 242 Summitt Wilham & Chnstlne 2R $17613 $24 481 $24481 $24 481 $24481 $14571 Mkt Stipulation 343 21 244 2R $17 613 $24 481 $24481 $24 481 $24481 $13499 343 21 245 2R $14235 $24481 $24481 $24 481 $24481 $12186 343 21 247 2R $14342 $24481 $24481 $24481 $24481 $12228 K - Land 344 13-0538 Landro Joseph 2R $35 000 $70 872 $70 872 $35 000 $35 000 $24 330 Mkt Stipulation 344 13-053C 2R $35 000 $70 808 $70 808 $35 000 $35 000 $24316 BLand 227-15124 Alba Stephanie 2R ? $224 870 $224 870 $224 870 $224 870 $195980 Mkt BLand 347-02 018A Alba Andre & Stephanie 2R ? $1 244250 $1 244 250 $1 244 250 $776 300 $426 634 Mkt Page 5 of 14 October 3, 2008 112029AM HEARING OFFICER S RECOMMENDATION Parcel Owner's Tax Legal Owner's Assessor's Assessor's Assessor's BofE LPV DecIsion Comments Number Name Agents Class Opinion Original Revised BOE DeCISion I Name (FCV) (FCV) (FCV) (FCV) (FCV) 8 Land 347 02-0188 Alba Andre & Stephanie 2R ? $379 865 $379865 $379 865 $236 950 $130222 Mkt 8 Land 347-02-018F Alba Andre & Stephanie 2R ? $492 646 $492 646 $492 646 $307 300 $159895 Mkt 8 Land 347-02-018G Alba Andre & Stephanie 2R ? $17955 $17955 $17955 $11 200 $5 828 Mkt K - Land 402-22 110 Peterson Scott 2R $104232 $312659 $312659 $208 978 $208 978 $100869 Mkt Stipulation K - Land 402-66-046 Andrews Weston 8 2R $52 400 $84410 $84410 $78959 $78 959 $45461 Mkt K - Land 402-66-068 Andrews Weston 8 2R $52 400 $84410 $84410 $78 959 $78 959 $45 461 Mkt K Land 320-49-001 8enettl Greg 2R $5 000 $28212 $28212 $12750 $12750 $3 626 Mkt 320-49-002 2R $5 000 $28 499 $28 499 $12750 $12750 $3 630 320-49-003 2R $5 000 $28 482 $28 482 $12750 $12750 $3 630 320-49 004 2R $5 000 $28 464 $28 464 $12750 $12750 $3 630 320-49-005 2R $5 000 $28 446 $28 446 $12750 $12750 $3 629 320-49-006 2R $5 000 $28 428 $28 428 $12750 $12750 $3 629 320-49-007 2R $5 000 $28414 $28414 $12750 $12750 $3 629 320-49-008 2R $5 000 $24 609 $24 609 $12750 $12750 $3 570 320-49-009 2R $5 000 $33551 $33 551 $12750 $12750 $3 709 320-49-010 2R $7 000 $68 235 $68 235 $12750 $12750 $4 256 320-49-011 2R $5 000 $34 968 $34 968 $12750 $12750 $3731 320-49-012 2R $5 000 $24 868 $24 868 $12750 $12750 $3574 320-49-013 2R $5 000 $28 638 $28 638 $12750 $12750 $3 632 320-49-014 2R $5 000 $28 620 $28 620 $12750 $12750 $3 632 320-49-015 2R $5 000 $28 602 $28 602 $12750 $12750 $3 632 320-49-016 2R $5 000 $28 585 $28 585 $12750 $12750 $3 632 320-49 017 2R $5 000 $28 570 $28 570 $12750 $12750 $3 632 320-49-018 2R $5 000 $28 553 $28 553 $12750 $12750 $3631 0912412008 K - Land 208-06-017 Capltalone LLC 81 Rustvang Land 2R $5 895 $29 476 $29 476 Withdrawn 208-06-023 Capltalone LLC 81 Rustvang Land 2R $7 508 $37 542 $37 542 208-06-024 Capltalone LLC 81 Rustvang Land 2R $17 901 $89 505 $89 505 208-06-025 Caprtalone LLC 81 Rustvang Land 2R $16080 $80 399 $80 399 208-06-026 Capltalone LLC 81 Rustvang Land 2R $13968 $69 842 $69 842 K - Land 208 36-001 Capltalone LLC 81 Rustvang Land 2R $2 036 $10180 $8 848 Withdrawn 20836-008 Capltalone LLC 81 Rustvang Land 2R $2132 $10658 $10658 20836009 Capltalone LLC 81 Rustvang Land 2R $2510 $12551 $10 911 20836-010 Capltalone LLC 81 Rustvang Land 2R $2510 $12551 $10911 20836-011 Capltalone LLC 81 Rustvang Land 2R $2510 $12551 $10911 20836-012 Capltalone LLC 81 Rustvang Land 2R $2 510 $12551 $10 911 208 36 013 Capltalone LLC 81 Rustvang Land 2R $2 399 $11 997 $10429 20836-014 Capltalone LLC 81 Rustvang Land 2R $2 399 $11 997 $10429 20836015 Capltalone LLC 81 Rustvang Land 2R $2 399 $11 997 $10429 208-36-016 Capltalone LLC 81 Rustvang Land 2R $2421 $12 106 $10522 208 36-017 Capltalone LLC 81 Rustvang Land 2R $2421 $12106 $10522 20836-018 Capltalone LLC 81 Rustvang Land 2R $2 399 $11 997 $10429 20836-019 Capltalone LLC 81 Rustvang Land 2R $2 399 $11 997 $10429 Page 6 of 14 October 3, 2008 112029AM HEARING OFFICER S RECOMMENDATION Parcel Owner's Tax Legal Owner's Assessor's Assessor's Assessor's BofE LPV DecIsion Comments Number Name Agents Class Opinion Original Revised BOE DecIsion I Name (FCV) (FCY) (FCV) (FCY) (FCY) 20836-020 Capltalone LLC 81 Rustvang Land 2R $1 863 $9313 $9313 20836-021 Capltalone LLC 81 Rustvang Land 2R $1 830 $9 151 $9 151 20836-022 Capltalone LLC 81 Rustvang Land 2R $2215 $11 075 $9 626 20836-023 Caprtalone LLC 81 Rustvang Land 2R $2215 $11 075 $9 626 20836-024 Capltalone LLC 81 Rustvang Land 2R $2215 $11 075 $9 626 20836-025 Capltalone LLC 81 Rustvang Land 2R $2 215 $11 075 $9 626 20836-026 Capltalone LLC 81 Rustvang Land 2R $2 003 $10015 $10015 B - Land 21313006 Tegtow Roy 23 et al 2R $1930176 $9 650 880 $3 504 000 $3 504 000 $3 504 000 $1 868 738 Mid BLand 213 13-048 Eloy 19K LLC 2R $1 529474 $7 647 370 $4 158 384 $4 158 384 $4 158 384 $3 673 882 Mkt BLand 21313-098 Streyle Dewayne & Mona 2R $3860352 $19301760 $5 248 000 Withdrawn BLand 213 13 101 Jorde Jeffrey 15 2R $132881 $664 403 $180646 Withdrawn 213 13 102 Jorde Jeffrey 15 2R $2 967 223 $14836 117 $4 033 826 BLand 213 13 103 Knorr Robert & Chen & Robert 2R $210389 $1 051 946 $1 051 946 $476984 $476 984 $476 984 Mid 213 13 104 Knorr Robert & Chen & Robert 2R $241 393 $1 206963 $1 206963 $547274 $547274 $547274 213 13 106 Knorr Robert & Chen & Robert 2R $168890 $844 452 $844 452 $382 900 $382 900 $382 900 BLand 21314055 StenehJem Leland M Jr 2R $1 420 982 $7104912 $1 893700 $1 893700 $1 893700 $1 893700 Mid BLand 213-14056 Vintage Ranch Investments LLC 2R $1 122078 $5610389 $2582010 Withdrawn BLand 21332-002 Knorr Robert & Chen & Robert 2R $589 932 $2 949 658 $2949658 $1 429874 $1 429874 $867 524 Mkt BLand 21337-002 Hendnx Launn M & Thomas Jenkins 2R $782 653 $3913263 $1 959932 $1 959932 $1 959932 $1 390739 Mkt 21337-003 Hendnx Launn M & Thomas Jenkins 2R $763 205 $3816027 $1 911 232 $1 911 232 $1 911 232 $1 541 051 B - Land 213 76-023 Nationwide Homes Development LLC 2R $15972 $79 859 $59755 $59 755 $59755 $59 755 Mkt 213 76-024 Nationwide Homes Development LLC 2R $14197 $70 985 $59755 $59 755 $59755 $59 755 213-76-025 Nationwide Homes Development LLC 2R $16563 $82816 $59755 $59 755 $59 755 $59 755 213 76 026 Nationwide Homes Development LLC 2R $16563 $82816 $59755 $59 755 $59755 $59 755 21376-027 Nationwide Homes Development LLC 2R $18338 $91 689 $59 755 $59755 $59755 $59755 21376-028 Nationwide Homes Development LLC 2R $18338 $91 689 $59755 $59 755 $59 755 $59755 213 76-035 Nationwide Homes Development LLC 2R $24 253 $121 267 $59755 $59 755 $59755 $59 755 21376-041 Nationwide Homes Development LLC 2R $24 253 $121 267 $59755 $59 755 $59755 $59 755 213 76-042 Nationwide Homes Development LLC 2R $22 479 $112394 $59755 $59 755 $59755 $59 755 213 76-043 Nationwide Homes Development LLC 2R $37056 $185282 $94 350 $94 350 $94 350 $94 350 213-76-044 Nationwide Homes Development LLC 2R $33114 $165572 $94 350 $94 350 $94 350 $94 350 213 76-045 Nationwide Homes Development LLC 2R $28 384 $141918 $94 350 $94 350 $94 350 $94 350 21376-046 Nationwide Homes Development LLC 2R $32 326 $161 629 $59 755 $59 755 $59755 $59 755 21376-047 Nationwide Homes Development LLC 2R $36 268 $181 340 $59 755 $59755 $59 755 $59755 21376-074 Nationwide Homes Development LLC 2R $17 346 $86 728 $78 625 $78625 $78 625 $78 625 213 76 076 Nationwide Homes Development LLC 2R $17346 $86 728 $78 625 $78625 $78 625 $78 625 21376116 Nationwide Homes Development LLC 2R $16563 $82816 $44 030 $44 030 $44 030 $44 030 213 76 133 Nationwide Homes Development LLC 2R $19 711 $98 555 $78 625 $78 625 $78 625 $78 625 21376134 Nationwide Homes Development LLC 2R $18922 $94612 $78 625 $78 625 $78 625 $78 625 213 82-008 Nationwide Homes Development LLC 2R $24 253 $121 267 $59755 $59 755 $59755 $59755 213-82-009 Nationwide Homes Development LLC 2R $24 253 $121267 $59755 $59 755 $59 755 $59 755 213 82 011 Nationwide Homes Development LLC 2R $23 070 $115351 $59755 $59 755 $59 755 $59 755 213-82-012 Nationwide Homes Development LLC 2R $24 845 $124224 $59755 $59 755 $59 755 $59755 213-82-013 Nationwide Homes Development LLC 2R $23 662 $118309 $59755 $59 755 $59 755 $59 755 213-82-014 Nationwide Homes Development LLC 2R $23 662 $118309 $59 755 $59 755 $59 755 $59 755 Page 7 of 14 October 3, 2008 112029AM HEARING OFFICER S RECOMMENDATION Parcel Owner's Tax Legal Owner's Assessor's Assessor's Assessor's BofE LPY DecIsion Comments Number Name Agents Class Opinion Original ReVised BOE DeCISion I Name (FCY) (FCY) (FCY) (FCY) (FeY) 213-82-015 Nationwide Homes Development LLC 2R $23 070 $115351 $59755 $59 755 $59755 $59 755 213-82-016 Nationwide Homes Development LLC 2R $21 887 $109436 $59755 $59 755 $59755 $59755 213-82-018 Nationwide Homes Development LLC 2R $21 887 $109436 $59755 $59 755 $59755 $59755 213 82-019 Nationwide Homes Development LLC 2R $26 620 $133098 $59755 $59 755 $59755 $59 755 213-82-020 Nationwide Homes Development LLC 2R $20113 $100563 $59755 $59 755 $59755 $59 755 213-82-021 Nationwide Homes Development LLC 2R $24 845 $124224 $59755 $59 755 $59755 $59 755 213-82-024 Nationwide Homes Development LLC 2R $43 183 $215914 $59755 $59 755 $59 755 $59 755 213-82-025 Nationwide Homes Development LLC 2R $21 296 $106478 $59755 $59 755 $59 755 $59 755 213-82-026 Nationwide Homes Development LLC 2R $20 499 $102497 $59 755 $59 755 $59755 $59 755 213-82-027 Nationwide Homes Development LLC 2R $21 288 $106439 $59755 $59 755 $59755 $59755 213-82028 Nationwide Homes Development LLC 2R $20 499 $102497 $59 755 $59 755 $59755 $59 755 213-82-035 Nationwide Homes Development LLC 2R $22 076 $110381 $59755 $59 755 $59755 $59 755 213-82-037 Nationwide Homes Development LLC 2R $21 288 $106439 $59755 $59 755 $59755 $59 755 213-82-047 Nationwide Homes Development LLC 2R $26 620 $133098 $59755 $59 755 $59 755 $59 755 213-82-048 Nationwide Homes Development LLC 2R $23 662 $118309 $59755 $59755 $59755 $59 755 213-82-049 Nationwide Homes Development LLC 2R $20 704 $103520 $59 755 $59 755 $59755 $59 755 213-82051 Nationwide Homes Development LLC 2R $21 296 $106478 $59755 $59 755 $59755 $59755 213-82-052 Nationwide Homes Development LLC 2R $20 499 $102797 $59755 $59 755 $59755 $59 755 213-82-053 Nationwide Homes Development LLC 2R $20 113 $100563 $59755 $59 755 $59755 $59755 213-82-055 Nationwide Homes Development LLC 2R $40817 $204 083 $59755 $59 755 $59 755 $59 755 213-82-056 Nationwide Homes Development LLC 2R $38 450 $192252 $59755 $59 755 $59755 $59755 213-82-057 Nationwide Homes Development LLC 2R $21 296 $106478 $59755 $59 755 $59755 $59 755 213 82-058 Nationwide Homes Development LLC 2R $23 070 $115351 $59 755 $59 755 $59755 $59 755 213-82 059 Nationwide Homes Development LLC 2R $24 253 $121 267 $59755 $59 755 $59 755 $59755 213-82-060 Nationwide Homes Development LLC 2R $22479 $112 394 $59755 $59 755 $59 755 $59 755 213-82-061 Nationwide Homes Development LLC 2R $23 662 $118309 $59755 $59 755 $59 755 $59755 213-82-062 Nationwide Homes Development LLC 2R $20 704 $103520 $59 755 $59755 $59 755 $59755 213-82-063 Nationwide Homes Development LLC 2R $24 845 $124224 $59755 $59 755 $59755 $59755 213-82-064 Nationwide Homes Development LLC 2R $21 887 $109436 $59755 $59755 $59 755 $59755 213-82-065 Nationwide Homes Development LLC 2R $26 028 $130140 $59 755 $59 755 $59 755 $59755 213-82-072 Nationwide Homes Development LLC 2R $33 903 $169514 $94 350 $94 350 $94 350 $94 350 213-82-073 Nationwide Homes Development LLC 2R $43 364 $216820 $94 350 $94 350 $94 350 $94 350 213-82-074 Nationwide Homes Development LLC 2R $25 230 $126150 $94 350 $94 350 $94 350 $94 350 213 82-075 Nationwide Homes Development LLC 2R $18922 $94612 $94 350 $94 350 $94 350 $94 350 213-82-076 Nationwide Homes Development LLC 2R $19711 $98 555 $94 350 $94 350 $94 350 $94 350 213-82-077 Nationwide Homes Development LLC 2R $22 865 $114323 $94 350 $94 350 $94 350 $94 350 213-82078 Nationwide Homes Development LLC 2R $24 442 $122208 $94 350 $94 350 $94 350 $94 350 213 82-079 Nationwide Homes Development LLC 2R $28 384 $141918 $94 350 $94 350 $94 350 $94 350 213-82-083 Nationwide Homes Development LLC 2R $35 480 $177 398 $94 350 $94 350 $94 350 $94 350 213-82-084 Nationwide Homes Development LLC 2R $21 887 $109436 $59755 $59755 $59 755 $59755 213-82-085 Nationwide Homes Development LLC 2R $31 537 $157687 $94 350 $94 350 $94 350 $94 350 213-82086 Nationwide Homes Development LLC 2R $28 384 $141 918 $94 350 $94 350 $94 350 $94 350 21382087 Nationwide Homes Development LLC 2R $29961 $149803 $94 350 $94 350 $94 350 $94 350 213-82-088 Nationwide Homes Development LLC 2R $23 662 $118309 $59 755 $59755 $59 755 $59755 213-82-089 Nationwide Homes Development LLC 2R $27 211 $136055 $59 755 $59755 $59755 $59755 Page 8 of 14 October 3 2008 11 20 29 AM HEARING OFFICER S RECOMMENDATION Parcel Owner's Tax Legal Owner's Assessor's Assessor's Assessor's BofE LPV DecIsion Comments Number Name Agent s Class Opinion Onglnal Revised BOE DecIsion I Name (FCV) (FCV) (FCV) (FCV) (FCV) 213-82 113 Nationwide Homes Development LLC 2R $22 076 $110381 $78 625 $78 625 $78 625 $78 625 213-82114 Nationwide Homes Development LLC 2R $19711 $98 555 $78 625 $78 625 $78 625 $78 625 213-82 119 Nationwide Homes Development LLC 2R $19711 $98 555 $78 625 $78 625 $78 625 $78 625 213 82 121 Nationwide Homes Development LLC 2R $22 076 $110381 $78 625 $78 625 $78 625 $78 625 213 82 122 Nationwide Homes Development LLC 2R $19711 $98 555 $78 625 $78 625 $78 625 $78 625 213 82 123 Nationwide Homes Development LLC 2R $18922 $94612 $78 625 $78 625 $78 625 $78 625 213-82 124 Nationwide Homes Development LLC 2R $18922 $94612 $78 625 $78 625 $78 625 $78 625 213-82 128 Nationwide Homes Development LLC 2R $18922 $94612 $78 625 $78 625 $78 625 $78 625 S Land 213-74-003 Laughlin Ranch LLC 2R $168 161 $840 804 $840 804 Withdrawn S Land 213-75-008 Knorr Family LLC 2R $602 493 $3012463 $3012463 $1 549206 $1 549206 $1019207 Mkt 21375-012 Knorr Family LLC 2R $123423 $617115 $617115 $318134 $318134 $208 520 S - Land 21375-010 Gray Squirrel Enterprises LLC 2R $452 278 $2261 392 $1 557416 $1 557416 $1 557416 $1 070548 Mkt S Land 213-81 003 Laughlin Ranch LLC 2R $1 051 916 $5 259 582 $4 790 187 Withdrawn S Land 213-81-005 Laughlin Ranch LLC 2R $48274 $241 373 $241 373 N Change N Change N Change N/A Spirt - Sep Notice 213-81-006 Laughlin Ranch LLC 2R $48 001 $240 009 $240 009 N-Change N Change N-Change N/A Spirt Sep Notice S - Land 213-82146 Stlnkweed Investment Co 2R $154 563 $772813 $224 840 Withdrawn 213-82148 Stlnkweed Investment Co 2R $66 695 $333474 $97 020 S Land 21382 149 Orange Coast Commercial Properties 2R $205 378 $1 026889 $370 055 Withdrawn S Land 21382 143 Atlantis Investments LLC 2R $493 782 $2 468 962 $2 468 962 $610418 $455 528 Mkt 213-82 150 Atlantis Investments LLC 2R $110629 $553 144 $553144 $120698 $120698 S - Land 213 90-001 SHC Pinnacle LLC 2R $671 $3 354 $3 354 ~ WIthdrawn 21390-002 SHC Pinnacle LLC 2R $671 $3 354 $3 354 21390-003 SHC Pinnacle LLC 2R $671 $3 354 $3 354 21390-004 SHC Pinnacle LLC 2R $671 $3 354 $3 354 21390-005 SHC Pinnacle LLC 2R $671 $3 354 $3 354 213 90-006 SHC Pinnacle LLC 2R $671 $3 354 $3 354 213 90-007 SHC Pinnacle LLC 2R $671 $3 354 $3 354 213 90-008 SHC Pinnacle LLC 2R $671 $3 354 $3 354 213 90-009 SHC Pinnacle LLC 2R $671 $3 354 $3 354 21390-010 SHC Pinnacle LLC 2R $671 $3 354 $3 354 213-90-011 SHC Pinnacle LLC 2R $671 $3 354 $3 354 213 90-012 SHC Pinnacle LLC 2R $671 $3 354 $3 354 21390-013 SHC Pinnacle LLC 2R $671 $3 354 $3 354 21390-014 SHC Pinnacle LLC 2R $671 $3 354 $3 354 213 90-015 SHC Pinnacle LLC 2R $671 $3 354 $3 354 213 90 016 SHC Pinnacle LLC 2R $671 $3 354 $3 354 21390-017 SHC Pinnacle LLC 2R $671 $3 354 $3 354 21390-018 SHC Pinnacle LLC 2R $671 $3 354 $3 354 21390019 SHC Pinnacle LLC 2R $671 $3 354 $3 354 213 90 020 SHC Pinnacle LLC 2R $671 $3 354 $3 354 213-90-021 SHC Pinnacle LLC 2R $671 $3 354 $3 354 213 90-022 SHC Pinnacle LLC 2R $671 $3 354 $3 354 213 90-023 SHC Pinnacle LLC 2R $671 $3 354 $3 354 21390-024 SHC Pinnacle LLC 2R $671 $3 354 $3 354 213 90-025 SHC Pinnacle LLC 2R $671 $3 354 $3 354 Page 9 of 14 October 3 2008 112029AM HEARING OFFICER 5 RECOMMENDATION Parcel Owner's Tax Legal Owner's Assessor's Assessor's Assessor's BofE LPV DecIsion Comments Number Name Agents Class Opinion Original Revised BOE DecIsion I Name (FCV) (FCV) (FCV) (FCV) (FCV) 213 90-026 SHC Pinnacle LLC 2R $671 $3 354 $3 354 21390-027 SHC Pinnacle LLC 2R $671 $3 354 $3 354 21390-028 SHC Pinnacle LLC 2R $671 $3 354 $3 354 21390-029 SHC Pinnacle LLC 2R $671 $3 354 $3 354 21390-030 SHC Pinnacle LLC 2R $671 $3 354 $3 354 21390-031 SHC Pinnacle LLC 2R $671 $3 354 $3 354 21390032 SHC Pinnacle LLC 2R $671 $3 354 $3 354 21390-033 SHC Pinnacle LLC 2R $671 $3 354 $3 354 213-90-034 SHC Pinnacle LLC 2R $671 $3 354 $3 354 213 90-035 SHC Pinnacle LLC 2R $671 $3 354 $3 354 21390-036 SHC Pinnacle LLC 2R $671 $3 354 $3 354 21390-037 SHC Pinnacle LLC 2R $671 $3 354 $3 354 213 90-038 SHC Pinnacle LLC 2R $671 $3 354 $3 354 21390-039 SHC Pinnacle LLC 2R $671 $3 354 $3 354 21390-040 SHC Pinnacle LLC 2R $671 $3 354 $3 354 213-90-041 SHC Pinnacle LLC 2R $671 $3 354 $3 354 213-90-042 SHC Pinnacle LLC 2R $671 $3 354 $3 354 21390-043 SHC Pinnacle LLC 2R $671 $3 354 $3 354 21390-044 SHC Pinnacle LLC 2R $671 $3 354 $3 354 213 90-045 SHC Pinnacle LLC 2R $671 $3 354 $3 354 213 90-046 SHC Pinnacle LLC 2R $671 $3 354 $3 354 21390-047 SHC Pinnacle LLC 2R $671 $3 354 $3 354 21390-048 SHC Pinnacle LLC 2R $671 $3 354 $3 354 21390-049 SHC Pinnacle LLC 2R $671 $3 354 $3 354 213-90-050 SHC Pinnacle LLC 2R $671 $3 354 $3 354 213 90-051 SHC Pinnacle LLC 2R $671 $3 354 $3 354 213 90-052 SHC Pinnacle LLC 2R $671 $3 354 $3 354 21390-053 SHC Pinnacle LLC 2R $671 $3 354 $3 354 21390-054 SHC Pinnacle LLC 2R $671 $3 354 $3 354 213-90-055 SHC Pinnacle LLC 2R $671 $3 354 $3 354 213-90-056 SHC Pinnacle LLC 2R $671 $3 354 $3 354 213 90 057 SHC Pinnacle LLC 2R $671 $3 354 $3 354 21390-058 SHC Pinnacle LLC 2R $671 $3 354 $3 354 21390-059 SHC Pinnacle LLC 2R $671 $3 354 $3 354 21390-060 SHC Pinnacle LLC 2R $671 $3 354 $3 354 21390-061 SHC Pinnacle LLC 2R $671 $3 354 $3 354 213 90-062 SHC Pinnacle LLC 2R $671 $3 354 $3 354 213-90-063 SHC Pinnacle LLC 2R $671 $3 354 $3 354 21390-064 SHC Pinnacle LLC 2R $671 $3 354 $3 354 21390-065 SHC Pinnacle LLC 2R $671 $3 354 $3 354 21390-066 SHC Pinnacle LLC 2R $671 $3 354 $3 354 21390-067 SHC Pinnacle LLC 2R $671 $3 354 $3 354 21390-068 SHC Pinnacle LLC 2R $671 $3 354 $3 354 213 90-069 SHC Pinnacle LLC 2R $671 $3 354 $3 354 213 90 070 SHC Pinnacle LLC 2R $671 $3 354 $3 354 Page 10 of 14 October 3, 2008 112029AM HEARING OFFICER S RECOMMENDATION Parcel Owner's Tax Legal Owner's Assessor's Assessor's Assessor's BofE LPV DecIsion Comments Number Name Agent s Class Opinion Onglnal Revised BOE DecIsion I Name (FCV) (FCV) (FCV) (FCV) (FCV) 213 90-071 BHC Pinnacle LLC 2R $671 $3 354 $3 354 21390-072 BHC Pinnacle LLC 2R $671 $3 354 $3 354 21390073 BHC Pinnacle LLC 2R $671 $3 354 $3 354 21390-074 BHC Pinnacle LLC 2R $671 $3 354 $3 354 21390-075 BHC Pinnacle LLC 2R $671 $3 354 $3 354 213-90-076 BHC Pinnacle LLC 2R $671 $3 354 $3 354 21390077 BHC Pinnacle LLC 2R $671 $3 354 $3 354 213 90-078 BHC Pinnacle LLC 2R $671 $3 354 $3 354 21390079 BHC Pinnacle LLC 2R $671 $3 354 $3 354 213 90-080 BHC Pinnacle LLC 2R $671 $3 354 $3 354 213 90-081 BHC Pinnacle LLC 2R $671 $3 354 $3 354 21390-082 BHC Pinnacle LLC 2R $671 $3 354 $3 354 21390-083 BHC Pinnacle LLC 2R $671 $3 354 $3 354 21390-084 BHC Pinnacle LLC 2R $671 $3 354 $3 354 213 90 085 BHC Pinnacle LLC 2R $671 $3 354 $3 354 213 90-086 BHC Pinnacle LLC 2R $671 $3 354 $3 354 213 90-087 BHC Pinnacle LLC 2R $671 $3 354 $3 354 21390-088 BHC Pinnacle LLC 2R $671 $3 354 $3 354 21390-089 BHC Pinnacle LLC 2R $671 $3 354 $3 354 213 90-090 BHC Pinnacle LLC 2R $671 $3 354 $3 354 21390-091 BHC Pinnacle LLC 2R $671 $3 354 $3 354 213 90-092 BHC Pinnacle LLC 2R $671 $3 354 $3 354 213 90 093 BHC Pinnacle LLC 2R $671 $3 354 $3 354 213 90-094 BHC Pinnacle LLC 2R $671 $3 354 $3 354 21390-095 BHC Pinnacle LLC 2R $671 $3 354 $3 354 21390-096 BHC Pinnacle LLC 2R $671 $3 354 $3 354 21390-097 BHC Pinnacle LLC 2R $671 $3 354 $3 354 21390-098 BHC Pinnacle LLC 2R $671 $3 354 $3 354 213 90-099 BHC Pinnacle LLC 2R $671 $3 354 $3 354 21390100 BHC Pinnacle LLC 2R $671 $3 354 $3 354 21390101 BHC Pinnacle LLC 2R $664 $3 320 $3 320 B - Land 21393-004 Canyons At Bullhead LLC 2R $4 611 $23 056 $23 056 $23 056 $23 056 $14712 Mkt 21393-020 Canyons At Bullhead LLC 2R $4 009 $20 043 $20 043 $20 043 $20 043 $12790 21393-021 Canyons At Bullhead LLC 2R $3 729 $18 645 $18645 $18 645 $18645 $11 898 21393-022 Canyons At Bullhead LLC 2R $3 729 $18645 $18645 $18645 $18 645 $11 898 213 93 023 Canyons At Bullhead LLC 2R $3774 $18870 $18870 $18 870 $18870 $12041 213 93-024 Canyons At Bullhead LLC 2R $3 871 $19355 $19355 $19355 $19355 $12351 21393-025 Canyons At Bullhead LLC 2R $3 899 $19494 $19494 $19494 $19494 $12439 21393-026 Canyons At Bullhead LLC 2R $3 860 $19301 $19301 $19301 $19301 $12316 21393-027 Canyons At Bullhead LLC 2R $3 703 $18515 $18515 $18515 $18515 $11 815 21393028 Canyons At Bullhead LLC 2R $3 576 $17881 $17 881 $17881 $17881 $11 410 21393-029 Canyons At Bullhead LLC 2R $3 630 $18150 $18150 $18150 $18 150 $11 582 213 93-030 Canyons At Bullhead LLC 2R $3 671 $18354 $18354 $18354 $18354 $11 712 21393031 Canyons At Bullhead LLC 2R $3 753 $18763 $18763 $18763 $18763 $11 973 21393-032 Canyons At Bullhead LLC 2R $3 927 $19634 $19634 $19634 $19634 $12529 Page 11 of 14 October 3, 2008 112029AM HEARING OFFICER 5 RECOMMENDATION Parcel Owner's Tax Legal Owner's Assessor's Assessor's Assessor's BofE LPV DecIsion Comments Number Name Agents Class Opinion Original Revised BOE DecIsion I Name (FCV) (FCV) (FCV) (FCV) (FCV) 21393-033 Canyons At Bullhead LLC 2R $3 871 $19355 $19355 $19355 $19355 $12351 21393-034 Canyons At Bullhead LLC 2R $3 800 $19000 $19000 $19000 $19000 $12 124 21393-035 Canyons At Bullhead LLC 2R $3 768 $18838 $18838 $18838 $18838 $12021 21393-036 Canyons At Bullhead LLC 2R $3 778 $18892 $18892 $18892 $18892 $12055 21393-037 Canyons At Bullhead LLC 2R $3 824 $19 118 $19 118 $19 118 $19 118 $12199 213 93-038 Canyons At Bullhead LLC 2R $3 882 $19408 $19408 $19408 $19408 $12384 213 93-039 Canyons At Bullhead LLC 2R $3931 $19656 $19656 $19656 $19656 $12543 213 93-040 Canyons At Bullhead LLC 2R $3981 $19903 $19903 $19903 $19903 $12700 21393041 Canyons At Bullhead LLC 2R $4019 $20 097 $20 097 $20 097 $20 097 $12824 21393-042 Canyons At Bullhead LLC 2R $4 037 $20 183 $20 183 $20 183 $20 183 $12879 21393-043 Canyons At Bullhead LLC 2R $1 030 $20151 $20151 $20151 $20151 $12859 213 93-044 Canyons At Bullhead LLC 2R $4 000 $20 000 $20 000 $20 000 $20 000 $12762 213 93-045 Canyons At Bullhead LLC 2R $3974 $19871 $19871 $19871 $19871 $12680 213 93-046 Canyons At Bullhead LLC 2R $3 897 $19484 $19 484 $19484 $19484 $12433 21393-047 Canyons At Bullhead LLC 2R $3 572 $17 859 $17859 $17 859 $17859 $11 396 213 93-048 Canyons At Bullhead LLC 2R $3 509 $17 547 $17 547 $17 547 $17 547 $11 197 213 93-049 Canyons At Bullhead LLC 2R $3 535 $17676 $17676 $17676 $17676 $11 279 21393-050 Canyons At Bullhead LLC 2R $3 867 $19333 $19333 $19333 $19333 $12337 213 93-051 Canyons At Bullhead LLC 2R $3 957 $19785 $19785 $19785 $19785 $12625 213-93-052 Canyons At Bullhead LLC 2R $4 039 $20 194 $20 194 $20 194 $20 194 $12886 213-93-053 Canyons At Bullhead LLC 2R $4 241 $21 205 $21 205 $21 205 $21 205 $13531 21393-054 Canyons At Bullhead LLC 2R $4 435 $22 173 $22 173 $22 173 $22 173 $14 149 21393-055 Canyons At Bullhead LLC 2R $4 428 $22 141 $22141 $22141 $22141 $14128 21393-056 Canyons At Bullhead LLC 2R $4 448 $22 238 $22 238 $22 238 $22 238 $14190 21393-057 Canyons At Bullhead LLC 2R $4 579 $22 894 $22 894 $22 894 $22 894 $14609 21393-058 Canyons At Bullhead LLC 2R $5 691 $28 456 $28 456 $28 456 $28 456 $18158 21393-059 Canyons At Bullhead LLC 2R $5 536 $27 682 $27 682 $27 682 $27 682 $17664 213 93-060 Canyons At Bullhead LLC 2R $4 557 $22 787 $22 787 $22 787 $22 787 $14541 21393-061 Canyons At Bullhead LLC 2R $5 207 $26 036 $26 036 $26 036 $26 036 $16614 21393-062 Canyons At Bullhead LLC 2R $4 297 $21 485 $21 485 $21 485 $21 485 $13710 213 93 063 Canyons At Bullhead LLC 2R $4 611 $23 056 $23 056 $23 056 $23 056 $14712 213 93-064 Canyons At Bullhead LLC 2R $4 846 $24 228 $24 228 $24 228 $24 228 $15460 21393-065 Canyons At Bullhead LLC 2R $4831 $24 153 $24 153 $24 153 $24153 $15412 213 93-066 Canyons At Bullhead LLC 2R $4 590 $22 948 $22 948 $22 948 $22 948 $14643 213 93-067 Canyons At Bullhead LLC 2R $3 836 $19182 $19182 $19182 $19182 $12240 213 93-068 Canyons At Bullhead LLC 2R $3811 $19053 $19053 $19053 $19053 $12158 213 93-069 Canyons At Bullhead LLC 2R $4 504 $22518 $22518 $22518 $22518 $14 369 21393-070 Canyons At Bullhead LLC 2R $5 082 $25 412 $25412 $25 412 $25412 $16216 213 93-071 Canyons At Bullhead LLC 2R $3 778 $18892 $18892 $18892 $18892 $12055 213 93-072 Canyons At Bullhead LLC 2R $3 677 $18386 $18386 $18386 $18386 $11 732 213 93 073 Canyons At Bullhead LLC 2R $3 753 $18763 $18763 $18763 $18763 $11 973 21393-074 Canyons At Bullhead LLC 2R $3 882 $19408 $19408 $19408 $19408 $12384 213 93-075 Canyons At Bullhead LLC 2R $3 824 $19 118 $19 118 $19118 $19 118 $12 199 213 93-076 Canyons At Bullhead LLC 2R $3 765 $18827 $18827 $18827 $18827 $12014 213-93-077 Canyons At Bullhead LLC 2R $3 972 $19860 $19860 $19860 $19860 $12673 Page 12 of 14 October 3, 2008 112029AM HEARING OFFICER 5 RECOMMENDATION Parcel Owner's Tax Legal Owner's Assessor's Assessor's Assessor's BofE LPV DecIsion Comments Number Name Agents Class Opinion Original ReVised BOE DecIsion I Name (FCY) (FCY) (FCY) (FCV) (FCY) 21393-078 Canyons At Bullhead LLC 2R $3 783 $18913 $18913 $18913 $18913 $12069 21393-079 Canyons At Bullhead LLC 2R $3 649 $18246 $18246 $18246 $18246 $11 643 213 93-080 Canyons At Bullhead LLC 2R $3 731 $18655 $18655 $18655 $18655 $11 904 21393081 Canyons At Bullhead LLC 2R $3 867 $19333 $19333 $19333 $19333 $12337 213-93-082 Canyons At Bullhead LLC 2R $5612 $28 058 $28 058 $28 058 $28 058 $17904 213-93 083 Canyons At Bullhead LLC 2R $5 332 $26 660 $26 660 $26 660 $26 660 $17 012 213 93-084 Canyons At Bullhead LLC 2R $5 259 $26 294 $26 294 $26 294 $26 294 $16779 21393-085 Canyons At Bullhead LLC 2R $3 946 $19731 $19731 $19731 $19731 $12591 21393-086 Canyons At Bullhead LLC 2R $4 013 $20 065 $20 065 $20 065 $20 065 $12804 21393-087 Canyons At Bullhead LLC 2R $4 045 $20 226 $20 226 $20 226 $20 226 $12906 21393088 Canyons At Bullhead LLC 2R $3981 $19903 $19903 $19903 $19903 $12700 213 93-089 Canyons At Bullhead LLC 2R $4 736 $23 680 $23 680 $23 680 $23 680 $15110 213 93-090 Canyons At Bullhead LLC 2R $5 883 $29414 $29414 $29414 $29414 $18769 21393-091 Canyons At Bullhead LLC 2R $4 189 $20947 $20 947 $20947 $20947 $13367 21393092 Canyons At Bullhead LLC 2R $4 054 $20 269 $20 269 $20 269 $20 269 $12934 213 93 093 Canyons At Bullhead LLC 2R $3916 $19581 $19581 $19581 $19581 $12495 213 93-094 Canyons At Bullhead LLC 2R $3916 $19581 $19581 $19581 $19581 $12495 213 93-095 Canyons At Bullhead LLC 2R $3916 $19581 $19581 $19581 $19581 $12495 21393096 Canyons At Bullhead LLC 2R $3 903 $19516 $19516 $19516 $19516 $12453 21393-097 Canyons At Bullhead LLC 2R $3 725 $18623 $18623 $18623 $18623 $11 884 21393-098 Canyons At Bullhead LLC 2R $3 725 $18623 $18623 $18623 $18623 $11 884 213 93-099 Canyons At Bullhead LLC 2R $3 802 $19010 $19010 $19010 $19010 $12131 21393100 Canyons At Bullhead LLC 2R $3916 $19581 $19581 $19581 $19581 $12495 21393 101 Canyons At Bullhead LLC 2R $3916 $19581 $19581 $19581 $19581 $12495 21393102 Canyons At Bullhead LLC 2R $3916 $19581 $19581 $19581 $19581 $12495 21393103 Canyons At Bullhead LLC 2R $3916 $19581 $19581 $19581 $19581 $12495 21393104 Canyons At Bullhead LLC 2R $3916 $19581 $19581 $19581 $19581 $12495 21393105 Canyons At Bullhead LLC 2R $3916 $19581 $19581 $19581 $19581 $12495 21393106 Canyons At Bullhead LLC 2R $3916 $19581 $19581 $19581 $19581 $12495 21393-107 Canyons At Bullhead LLC 2R $3916 $19 581 $19581 $19581 $19581 $12495 21393 108 Canyons At Bullhead LLC 2R $3916 $19 581 $19581 $19581 $19581 $12495 21393 109 Canyons At Bullhead LLC 2R $3916 $19581 $19581 $19581 $19581 $12495 21393110 Canyons At Bullhead LLC 2R $3916 $19581 $19581 $19581 $19581 $12495 213-93 111 Canyons At Bullhead LLC 2R $3916 $19 581 $19581 $19 581 $19581 $12495 21393 112 Canyons At Bullhead LLC 2R $3 916 $19581 $19581 $19 581 $19581 $12495 21393113 Canyons At Bullhead LLC 2R $3916 $19581 $19581 $19 581 $19581 $12495 213 93 114 Canyons At Bullhead LLC 2R $3916 $19581 $19581 $19581 $19581 $12495 213 93 115 Canyons At Bullhead LLC 2R $3916 $19581 $19581 $19581 $19581 $12495 213 93 116 Canyons At Bullhead LLC 2R $3916 $19581 $19581 $19581 $19581 $12495 21393117 Canyons At Bullhead LLC 2R $3 699 $18494 $18494 $18494 $18494 $11 801 21393-118 Canyons At Bullhead LLC 2R $3 688 $18440 $18440 $18440 $18440 $11 767 21393119 Canyons At Bullhead LLC 2R $3716 $18580 $18580 $18580 $18580 $11 856 21393 120 Canyons At Bullhead LLC 2R $3714 $18569 $18569 $18569 $18569 $11 849 21393 121 Canyons At Bullhead LLC 2R $3 927 $19 634 $19634 $19634 $19634 $12529 213-93122 Canyons At Bullhead LLC 2R $4 288 $21 442 $21 442 $21 442 $21 442 $13682 Page 13 of 14 October 3 2008 112029AM HEARING OFFICER S RECOMMENDATION Parcel Owner's Tax Legal Owner's Assessor's Assessor's Assessor's BofE LPV DecIsion Comments Number Name Agents Class Opinion Onglnal Revised BOE DeCISion I Name (FCY) (FCY) (FCY) (FCY) (FCV) 21393123 Canyons At Bullhead LLC 2R $4 288 $21 442 $21 442 $21 442 $21 442 $13682 21393 124 Canyons At Bullhead LLC 2R $4 288 $21 442 $21 442 $21 442 $21 442 $13682 213 93 125 Canyons At Bullhead LLC 2R $4 288 $21 442 $21 442 $21 442 $21 442 $13682 21393126 Canyons At Bullhead LLC 2R $6 797 $33 986 $33 986 $33 986 $33 986 $21 687 21393127 Canyons At Bullhead LLC 2R $4 105 $20 527 $20 527 $20 527 $20 527 $13099 213 93 139 Canyons At Bullhead LLC 2R $500 $506 726 $122342 $122342 $122342 $122342 21393140 Canyons At Bullhead LLC 2R $500 $375472 $90 653 $90 653 $90 653 $90 653 21393-141 Canyons At Bullhead LLC 2R $500 $731 580 $176630 $176630 $176630 $176 630 21393142 Canyons At Bullhead LLC 2R $500 $1 267 354 $305 986 $305 986 $305 986 $305 986 21393-143 Canyons At Bullhead LLC 2R $500 $717615 $173258 $173258 $173258 $173258 21393 144 Canyons At Bullhead LLC 2R $500 $416355 $1 000 $1 000 $1 000 $1 000 BLand 347 15-018 Capltalone LLC 2R $3731 $18654 $18654 Withdrawn B - Land 347-32 109A Strnkweed Investment Co 2R $1 550 $7748 $7748 Withdrawn 347 32-109B Strnkweed Investment Co 2R $3 372 $16861 $16861 B - Land 349-01 039 Elroy 19K LLC 2R $393 505 $1 967523 $1 967523 $1 967523 $1 967523 $1 150796 Mkt 349-01-040 Elroy 19K LLC 2R $549 226 $2746132 $2746132 $2746132 $2746132 $1606254 K - Land 209 13 001 De Narcus Craig 2R $400 000 $1 254 371 $1 254 371 $1 254 371 $1 254 371 $367 388 Mkt Page 14 of 14